Logo
PL EN IT
facebook.com logo linking to the social media profile linkedin.com logo linking to the social media profile twitter.com logo linking to the social media profile
PL EN IT
Eye icon: enable high-contrast mode A A

Low Down-Payment Insurance: Is It Worth Suing the Bank?

The issue of low deposit insurance for loans, particularly those taken out in Swiss francs, has recently attracted considerable consumer interest. However, the widely discussed judgment of the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection may not be sufficient to win a case. Borrowers considering bringing proceedings to recover insurance premiums paid should read our article.



The issue of low deposit insurance for loans, particularly those taken out in Swiss francs, but also in EURO and Polish zlotys, has recently attracted considerable consumer interest. Borrowers wondering whether it is worth suing their bank to recover premiums paid for low deposit insurance should read the information below.

What is low deposit insurance (UNWW)?

UNWW provides banks with security in the event of problems with loan repayments. Its purpose is to cover the risk of the borrower failing to repay the loan, and it is calculated on the amount representing the difference between the value of the property when the loan is granted and the deposit required by the bank at that time. This insurance primarily concerns people who have taken out a loan for, most commonly, more than 80% of the value of the property being purchased. The bank is the sole beneficiary, while the borrower bears the cost of the insurance.

Low deposit insurance as an unfair contract term?

In its judgment of 6 August 2009, the Court of Competition and Consumer Protection found the following contractual clause concerning a low deposit to be unfair: "The Borrower undertakes to establish the following security for the loan / final security arrangements: Accession to the General Low Deposit Insurance Agreement for housing loans with TU Europa S.A. The insurance period is (36/60) months. The insurance premium of … PLN is payable in advance for the entire insurance period and is non-refundable." According to the reasons for the judgment, the court found the inability to obtain a refund of the insurance premium to be unfair. Nevertheless, consumers with precisely this wording found themselves in a favourable position because, as an unfair contract term, the provision is not binding on them, meaning that the bank has no basis for charging them such a premium. 

Can an insurance clause worded differently be regarded as an unfair contract term?

Yes. The consumer must demonstrate that, in their case, the provision was not individually negotiated with them (and loan agreements tend to offer little scope for any negotiation). In addition, the court must find that the provision defines their rights and obligations in a manner contrary to good practice and grossly infringes their interests. It should be emphasised that the burden of proving these conditions rests with the consumer. 

Consumers are also increasingly drawing attention to the lack of equivalence between the parties’ obligations: the insured party is the bank, rather than the consumer, while the latter merely has to ‘finance’ the insurance without any influence over the choice of insurance company, the terms of the agreement with the insurer or the amount of the premium. Moreover, if an insured event occurs, the insurer will repay the loan but will have a right of recourse against the consumer. The consumer’s position will therefore remain unchanged: they will still have to repay the ‘loan’, only to the insurer. The consumer thus derives no benefit from this and merely finances protection against the bank’s risk. Banks take the view that the benefit is obtaining a loan despite having no deposit.

Is there a chance of winning the case?

The first judgments in favour of consumers have already been handed down on this issue, for example the judgment of the District Court for Wrocław–Śródmieście  of 6 March 2012, case no. IC494/11, the judgment of the District Court for Warszawa–Mokotów of 7 April 2014, case no. I C 2565/13, or the judgment of the Regional Court in Wrocław, Second Civil Appeals Division, of  13 August 2012, case no. II Ca 723/12. Nevertheless, it should be borne in mind that contrary judgments are also being handed down, dismissing claims or rejecting the arguments set out above. For example, in the recent judgment of the District Court for Warszawa-Mokotów in Warsaw of 10 December 2014, case no. I C 902/14, the court held that ‘the counterpart to the obligation to reimburse the cost of low deposit insurance … is precisely the loan, the access to money which the consumer obtains despite having neither their own funds nor adequate security’. Although that case was won, it was on other grounds, so basing a claim solely on the unfairness of the UNWW clause is risky.

It should be remembered that a case always concerns individual, specific circumstances, and the court always examines the merits of a claim in relation to the particular facts. Our firm recommends basing a claim on several independent grounds identified through an assessment of the facts of the case.

Is an individual claim or a group claim better?

Everyone must answer this question for themselves, taking the following facts into account. A group claim is undoubtedly cheaper, since the court fee (which the claimant must pay when filing the claim) is 3%, rather than 5%, of the value of the claim. Legal costs are minimised because of the number of people involved, and gathering evidence is easier: with more claimants, it is easier to provide all the necessary documents common to everyone or testimony from a certain number of people. There is also undoubtedly ‘strength in numbers’, which may not affect the court’s judgment but may influence the bank’s approach (although the banks’ position to date does not really suggest this). The main disadvantage of such group proceedings is that preparing the claim itself takes significantly longer (collecting documentation from each claimant and then preparing it for attachment to the claim), and unfortunately the proceedings themselves also take longer. Depending on the type of proceedings, they may be conducted to establish liability in principle rather than to obtain an award of specific sums (group proceedings require equal amounts in subgroups of at least two people). In that case, a successful outcome merely provides grounds for bringing further proceedings for payment. 

Is it worth it?

If you have low deposit insurance and are considering whether you have a chance of winning a case, it is certainly worth consulting an experienced lawyer. Although no lawyer can guarantee the outcome of proceedings, they can assess the evidence and your position. It is important to recognise that a claim does not have to be based solely on the argument that the low deposit insurance clause is an unfair contract term. Your claim may also be based on other grounds specific to your circumstances or to the particular bank, which will strengthen your evidential position. This is the case, for example, in proceedings currently being handled by our firm, where, after analysing the facts, we decided that the unfairness of the UNWW provision would be only a supporting argument. The claim is based on entirely different factual circumstances specific to the bank concerned, which we managed to establish.

If  you are considering bringing a claim against a bank concerning low deposit insurance, please get in touch.

I wish to emphasise that the information contained in this document is true and up to date at the time of publication on the website, but does not constitute legal advice. I can provide detailed advice only in response to a specific enquiry and in relation to particular facts. 

thumbnail

Easier withdrawal from online financial contracts? Proposed consumer rights and bank obligations in Poland

CATEGORY: News, Business law, Consumer law and GDPR, Banking disputes (CHF, WIBOR, SKD)
Entering into a financial contract online often takes only a few minutes. Exercising the right to withdraw from it can be considerably harder. Searching for the right form, calling a helpline or navigating unclear proced...
thumbnail

Trade marks in Poland: how to register a business name or logo and what does it cost?

CATEGORY: News, Intellectual property
A business name, a distinctive logo or a product sign is often developed long before the business starts trading. Entrepreneurs invest in promotion, build brand recognition and earn their customers’ trust. They do not al...
thumbnail

Higher notarial fees in Poland from 5 November 2026: how much will wills and inheritance matters cost?

CATEGORY: News, Family and inheritance law
From 5 November 2026, the maximum fees charged by Polish notaries for many notarial acts will increase. The changes affect, among other things, wills, declarations accepting or rejecting an inheritance, certification of...


We use cookies necessary for the website to function correctly. With your consent, we also use analytics cookies to help us understand how users interact with the site.

By choosing “Accept”, you consent to analytics cookies. By choosing “Decline”, you allow only necessary cookies. Simply browsing the site does not constitute consent.

For more information about cookies and the processing of personal data, see our Privacy Policy.