You have decided to pursue your rights and financial compensation from a hospital or another medical facility. Where should you start? What can you claim? How do you calculate the amount you can demand? What is the difference between damages for financial loss and compensation for non-pecuniary harm? We invite you to read this series of articles.
We have already decided that we want to pursue our rights and financial compensation from a hospital or another medical facility. What, then, can we claim? How do we calculate the amount we can demand? This paper discusses the main types of compensation claims, but an individual assessment will determine which specific claims we can bring in your case.
1. Damages for losses incurred. Under Article 444 § 1 of the Civil Code, where bodily injury or a health disorder is caused, compensation for pecuniary loss arising from personal injury covers all resulting costs. In particular, reimbursement may be sought for:
a) the costs of treatment, medicines and dressings. These are expenses associated with the diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation of the injured person.
b) the costs of obtaining medical records, including photocopies of medical histories, operation reports, consents to procedures, medical consultation records and diagnostic test results, supported by an invoice. Medical records are among the principal forms of evidence in medical litigation; these matters will be discussed in greater detail in a subsequent publication.
c) the costs of travel to medical facilities, calculated on the basis of the car’s average fuel consumption, make and engine capacity, and average fuel prices. Evidence: a printout of the route and a printout of the car’s average fuel consumption.
d) the costs of assistance from third parties. The cost of care provided by third parties is estimated on the basis of the Supreme Court judgment of 21 September 2005 (case no. V CK 150/05), which stated in its reasoning that the reference point for establishing (documenting) care costs should be the statutory minimum wage applicable at that time. The minimum wage for the year in question should be divided by the number of working hours in the month.
e) other costs arising in connection with medical malpractice, in particular specialist consultations, the costs of special nutrition and care during recovery, adapting a car, alterations to a home to meet the needs of a person with a disability, or reduced pay due to being on sick leave.
It is important that all the above costs should be supported by appropriate receipts, invoices, certificates and similar documents, so it is extremely important to document all these events from the outset.
2. Compensation for damage to health, suffering and non-pecuniary harm. Financial compensation payable to an injured person for non-pecuniary harm and suffering, both physical and psychological, is based on Article 445 § 1 of the Civil Code. The provisions in force do not specify precisely the amount of compensation that should be awarded. However, as the Supreme Court has repeatedly stated, determining the amount of compensation provided for in Article 445 § 1 of the Civil Code requires consideration of all circumstances relevant to assessing the extent of the harm suffered, such as the injured person’s age, the degree of physical and psychological suffering, its intensity and duration, the irreversible consequences of bodily injury or a health disorder (disability, disfigurement), the type of work performed, future prospects, a sense of being of no use to society, helplessness in life and other factors of a similar nature (Supreme Court judgment of 9.11.2007, case no. V CSK 245/07).
The above criteria establish the range within which compensation should fall. On the one hand, it should represent a real, economically meaningful value; on the other, it should be moderate, meaning a monetary amount kept within reasonable limits corresponding to current conditions and society’s average standard of living. Both the circumstances affecting the amount of compensation and the criteria for assessing them must be considered individually in relation to the particular injured person.
In recent years, a tendency towards higher compensation awards can be observed. Particular attention should be paid here to the Supreme Court judgment of 16 July 1997, case no. II CKN 273/97: ‘health is an especially valuable interest; awarding low amounts of compensation in cases of serious bodily injury leads to an undesirable devaluation of that interest’.
Determining the amount of compensation for non-pecuniary harm is the most difficult part of assessing compensation, and in this respect we recommend seeking assistance from professional legal representatives, who will help to estimate it taking account of current case law and the client’s circumstances.
3. Establishing liability for the future. The injured person may also seek a finding that, for example, a doctor or hospital is liable for further consequences of the medical procedure that may arise in the future. It should also be borne in mind that the client’s circumstances may be such that, for example, treatment and rehabilitation are still ongoing. There is therefore a possibility of consequences of the event arising that cannot be identified at present, as well as additional costs, mainly associated with rehabilitation, which likewise cannot currently be predicted.
Establishing an obligation to compensate for future damage does not require certainty that further damage will occur in the future. It is sufficient to establish a likelihood that the claimant’s current state of health does not yet reveal all the consequences of the bodily injury (Supreme Court judgment of 22 June 1978, IV CR 203/78).
Nevertheless, the current line of case law indicates that establishing compensation for the future tends to occur exclusively in relation to injured minors.
4. An award of periodic payments. Under Article 444 § 2 of the Civil Code, the injured person is entitled to claim periodic payments if they have wholly or partially lost their capacity for gainful employment, their needs have increased or their prospects of future success have diminished. These consequences should be lasting (which does not mean irreversible). Each of these circumstances may independently provide grounds for an award of periodic payments.
An increase in the injured person’s needs constitutes future damage. Periodic payments for increased needs concern situations where the injury makes it necessary to incur higher living costs to meet the injured person’s justified needs than before the injury occurred (e.g. the costs of medical consultations, care and medicines).
5. Financial compensation in connection with a breach of patients’ rights on account of an infringement of personal rights (Article 4(1) of the Act of 6 November 2008 on Patients’ Rights and the Commissioner for Patients’ Rights in conjunction with Article 448 of the Civil Code). A claim for compensation in connection with a breach of patients’ rights on account of an infringement of personal rights is an entirely different claim, with a separate factual and legal basis from Article 445 of the Civil Code, which compensates for the consequences of bodily injury or a health disorder. Article 4 of the Act on Patients’ Rights and the Commissioner for Patients’ Rights (hereinafter: ‘u.p.p.’) protects the patient’s dignity, privacy and autonomy, irrespective of the care taken in and effectiveness of the medical procedure (according to the Court of Appeal in Szczecin judgment of 2 August 2012, case no. I ACa 443/12). It should be noted that, according to legal scholarship, the injured person does not have to prove, or establish fault, as the basis of the claim; it is sufficient to identify a specific breach of patients’ rights in order to claim compensation.
To conclude, obtaining compensation for medical injury is not straightforward, and the proceedings themselves may be lengthy. For this reason, it is extremely important to prepare the evidence very carefully and to ensure that the compensation sought is close to the amount ultimately awarded by the court, given the issue of litigation costs.
Our Law Office provides comprehensive legal assistance aimed at taking specific steps where damage has occurred, to help injured persons pursue compensation claims. We advise our Clients on gathering appropriate medical records and specialist opinions and, above all, help to estimate the amount of compensation that may be obtained.
If you are wondering whether you have a chance of winning a medical malpractice case, including whether you will be able to prove your claim, we encourage you to contact our Law Office.
Converting a Civil-Law Partnership into a Commercial Company
Can a Blogger Be a Journalist? Can a Blog Be a Newspaper or Periodical?
Converting a Sole Trader into a Single-Member Company