Logo
PL EN IT
facebook.com logo linking to the social media profile linkedin.com logo linking to the social media profile twitter.com logo linking to the social media profile
PL EN IT
Eye icon: enable high-contrast mode A A

Medical Malpractice: What Is It and When Can a Patient Bring a Claim?

What is a medical error, also referred to as medical malpractice? How can compensation for such an error be obtained? How should you prepare for proceedings and what evidence will be needed? How much do such proceedings cost? You will find answers to these questions in our series of articles devoted to this subject.

Anna Borkowska

There is currently an increasing number of court cases concerning so-called medical errors. This is due to patients’ greater awareness of their rights and the possibility of pursuing claims relating to treatment, as well as a shift away from the previously widespread belief that the medical profession closes ranks and that winning a case is impossible. Articles reporting both further instances of medical errors and successful claims are appearing in the media with increasing frequency. Nevertheless, many injured patients give up pursuing their claims for fear of court proceedings that are exceptionally complicated because of their legal and medical complexities.  This study forms part of a series of articles devoted to medical error litigation.

So what is a medical error?

According to a definition developed by the Supreme Court as early as the 1950s (decision of 1 April 1955, case no. IV CR 39/54), ‘medical malpractice is an act (omission) by a doctor in the field of diagnosis and treatment that is inconsistent with medical knowledge accessible to that doctor. A doctor’s negligence in fulfilling the duty to provide care for a patient and in organising safety, hygiene and patient care does not constitute medical malpractice’. Nowadays, however, the term ‘medical error’ tends to be used rather than ‘medical malpractice’ or ‘doctor’s error’. 

Medical and legal literature introduces various classifications and categories of doctors’ errors. It should be remembered, however, that the category of medical error is of little significance from the perspective of civil liability.  The following categories of errors can be distinguished:

Organisational error:

A very common error of this kind is the defective organisation of the treatment process. For example, having two patients with the same first name and surname on the same ward at the same time gives rise to an organisational error that may manifest itself in the transfusion of incompatible blood as a result of confusing the patients. Such an error may involve referring a patient for an unnecessary operation on the basis of test results belonging to another patient with an identical first name and surname, or handing parents someone else’s baby following an accidental mix-up of newborns. This type of error is undoubtedly the easiest to prove.
 
Diagnostic error (misdiagnosis):

This error involves making an incorrect diagnosis as a result of a doctor’s conduct that is objectively inconsistent with the principles applicable in medicine.

A distinction is made between a negative diagnostic error (failure to identify an actual illness) and a positive diagnostic error (incorrectly identifying an illness that does not actually exist). 

A diagnostic error adversely affects the entire subsequent treatment process.

According to statistics, diagnostic errors in medical practice occur most commonly in surgery, obstetrics and gynaecology, oncology and cardiology. By way of example only, such an error occurred when a non-existent pregnancy was diagnosed solely on the basis of an ultrasound scan (Supreme Court judgment of 20 March 2002, case no. V CKN 909/00), or when a patient was diagnosed with a malignant kidney tumour, leading to unnecessary removal of the kidney and chemotherapy, whereas the patient had xanthogranulomatous pyelonephritis (Supreme Court judgment of 10 March 2006, IV CSK 80/05).

This is probably the most common medical error we encounter, and examples from the courts abound.

Prognostic error:

This type of error involves incorrect prognoses and predictions concerning  the patient’s future health. 

Therapeutic error (treatment error):

Such an error occurs mainly when an inappropriate treatment approach or method is chosen. This may include administering an unsuitable medicine to a patient. It is worth pointing out here that, under the Act of 6 November 2008 on Patients’ Rights and the Patient Ombudsman (Dz.U.2012.159, consolidated text), one of a patient’s rights is the right to healthcare services that meet the requirements of current medical knowledge.

When classifying errors, it is also necessary to mention so-called operative error, which is a particular form of therapeutic error. This involves performing a surgical procedure incorrectly.

To sum up, there are many types of medical errors, but their classification is a secondary issue. When such an event occurs, the central issue is proving the error: gathering evidence to establish the error and the person or persons responsible, so that, on the basis of those facts, a legal representative can also demonstrate a causal link between the doctor’s or doctors’ conduct and the resulting injury to health. These issues will be discussed in greater detail in the next publication.

Source: 

If you are wondering whether you have a chance of winning a medical error case, including whether you will be able to prove your claim, we encourage you to contact our firm. 

thumbnail

Converting a Civil-Law Partnership into a Commercial Company

CATEGORY: Publications, Business law
Conducting business through a civil law partnership (the ‘Partnership’) is the simplest arrangement used by entrepreneurs. The Partnership agreement requires only ordinary written form, and its operation is governed by t...
thumbnail

Can a Blogger Be a Journalist? Can a Blog Be a Newspaper or Periodical?

CATEGORY: Publications
Can you become a journalist by writing a blog? Can a blog be a daily newspaper or periodical? Registering a private blog as a daily newspaper or periodical is not ruled out.
thumbnail

Converting a Sole Trader into a Single-Member Company

CATEGORY: Publications, Business law
A sole proprietorship is a convenient but also the riskiest way of conducting business in Poland. At some stage, many entrepreneurs consider converting their business into a partnership or company. This article discusses...


We use cookies necessary for the website to function correctly. With your consent, we also use analytics cookies to help us understand how users interact with the site.

By choosing “Accept”, you consent to analytics cookies. By choosing “Decline”, you allow only necessary cookies. Simply browsing the site does not constitute consent.

For more information about cookies and the processing of personal data, see our Privacy Policy.